401k ROLLOVERS & IN-SERVICE DISTRIBUTIONS
Career Milestone to Strategic Opportunity
​For many people, a 401k rollover feels administrative – something to "take care of" after a job change or as retirement approaches. But the implications of your decision are far-reaching and extend well beyond where assets are held.
Rather than leaving decisions to default options, a rollover allows you to intentionally redesign how your retirement capital works for you. Once your assets reach a certain level, these decisions quietly shape taxes, flexibility, and long-term outcomes far more than most people expect.
​
We work with individuals who have accumulated meaningful retirement savings and want to be intentional about how those assets fit into a broader investment strategy. In those cases, a rollover is rarely just about moving money. It's about regaining control, improving coordination, tax-efficiency, managing risk deliberately, and better positioning your portfolio for the next phase of life.
WHEN ROLLOVERS TEND TO MATTER MORE THAN PEOPLE EXPECT
We typically see rollover decisions during moments of transition -- retirement, a career change, or a shift in compensation structure. Increasingly, we also see investors confronting rollover questions before retirement through in-service distributions, as balances grow and planning becomes more complex.​
​
In any case, it's a moment to reassess how risk is managed across your portfolio, whether your current investments are cost-effective and flexible, and how your retirement assets integrate with taxable accounts, trusts, and estate plans.
​
​At higher asset levels, these moments tend to concentrate multiple decisions into a short window of time. How assets are moved, how they are invested afterward, and how taxes are managed in the process can meaningfully influence outcomes years down the road.​
IN-SERVICE DISTRIBUTIONS: An Often-Overlooked Planning Opportunity
Many employer plans allow participants, often beginning at age 59 1/2, to roll a portion of their 401k into an IRA while still employed. When used intentionally, in-service distributions can create flexibility without requiring a full career exit.
​
Handled carefully, this may allow for:​
​
- Broader investment options
- More coordinated tax planning
- Early alignment with a long-term retirement income strategy
​
Handled casually, it can introduce unnecessary tax exposure or disrupt the structure of an otherwise well-designed plan. The difference is rarely the availability of the option. It's whether the decision is made with a clear understanding of trade-offs and timing.
YOUR MAIN ROLLOVER OPTIONS
How They Compare
1 - LEAVING ASSETS IN THE OLD 401k
In some cases, leaving assets in a former employers 401(k) can make sense. Plans may offer low cost, access to institutional share classes, or creditor protections that are valuable in specific situations. While this is the simplest option, simplicity can come at a cost, particularly for higher net worth investors. The larger your balance is, the more the constraints of your 401k plan can limit how effectively your portfolio can be managed over time.
​
Potential limitations include:​
- Investment menus are limited to what your employer plan offers
- Limited proactive risk management strategies
- Less flexibility for tax and income planning
- Ongoing plan fees, which most people don't even realize they are paying, that may not be competitive
2 - ROLLING ASSETS INTO A NEW 401k
This is another option that offers simplicity and convenience since you would essentially be consolidating two accounts into one. This approach may work well for some investors early in their career, but it often becomes less attractive as your wealth and financial complexity increase.
​
Potential limitations include:​
- Investment options remain pre-selected by your employer plan
- Portfolio customization is minimal
- Coordination with other assets can be difficult
3 - ROLLING ASSETS INTO A TRADITIONAL IRA
For many high net worth investors, this is where real strategic planning becomes possible, especially when risk management and tax considerations are integrated thoughtfully.
A rollover to a traditional IRA provides:
- Significantly broader investment choices and flexibility
- More precise portfolio construction
- Improved coordination with taxable and retirement accounts
4 - ROLLING ASSETS INTO A ROTH IRA
A Roth rollover can be powerful, but it is not universally appropriate.
​
Potential advantages include:​
- Tax-free growth and distributions
- Greater long-term tax certainty
- Estate planning benefits
​
However, Roth conversions involve upfront tax considerations and timing decisions that should be evaluated carefully in the context of your income, future tax brackets, and long-term objectives.
WHY AN IRA ROLLOVER OFFERS GREATER CONTROL & FLEXIBILITY
For investors with substantial retirement assets, IRAs typically offer advantages that employer plans simply cannot.​
With an IRA, you get expanded investment choices beyond the employer's pre-set "menu." Also, managing risk within an employer plan is typically limited to basic diversification, whereas an IRA allows for more sophisticated approaches. As wealth increases, investors really appreciate the freedom to design a portfolio aligned with their long-term goals, not their employer's defaults. Finally, IRAs allow for better integration with tax and estate planning strategies for ultimate efficiency.
​
This added flexibility allows portfolios to be structured intentionally, not generically, while still maintaining a disciplined, long-term focus.
WHERE WE SEE REGRET:
Usually Years Later
In hindsight, the most common regret we hear is not that a rollover was executed incorrectly, but that it was executed without context.
​
Assets were moved because it felt logical at the time — not because anyone paused to ask how the decision fit into taxes, future income, or the rest of the portfolio. Years later, when required distributions begin or tax brackets shift, the consequences become clearer, often at a time when the ability to course-correct is more limited.
​
Partnering with a fiduciary helps you see the big picture, ensuring today's financial choices don't become tomorrow’s regrets.
TYPICAL TIMELINES, RULES & DEADLINES TO KNOW
A 401k rollover is governed by rules that are specific, but not always intuitive. While many of these rules are designed to preserve tax-deferred status, timing and sequencing matter more than most investors realize.
​
After leaving an employer, most plans allow you to roll over your 401k without a strict deadline. However, how the rollover is executed matters. A direct rollover from the plan to an IRA generally avoids mandatory withholding and keeps the transaction tax-deferred. By contrast, taking a distribution personally, even temporarily, can introduce withholding requirements and tight redeposit timelines that increase the risk of unintended taxes.
​
For individuals who are still employed, in-service distributions add another layer of complexity. Many employer plans permit partial rollovers once you reach age 59½, but eligibility rules vary by plan. Some restrict how often distributions can be taken, while others limit which balances are eligible. When used thoughtfully, in-service distributions can create earlier flexibility and coordination opportunities. When used casually, they can unintentionally disrupt future tax planning.
​
Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) also affect rollover timing. Once RMDs begin, the required amount must be withdrawn before any rollover of remaining assets can occur for that year. This sequencing rule is often missed, and mistakes can result in penalties that are both avoidable and frustrating. Even investors who are years away from RMD age benefit from understanding how early rollover decisions influence future distribution requirements.
​
Finally, rollover decisions can affect planning strategies that are not immediately visible. Rolling assets into an IRA may impact the ability to execute backdoor Roth contributions, alter creditor protections, or eliminate the option to delay RMDs by continuing to work past traditional retirement age. None of these outcomes are inherently negative — but they underscore why rollover timing should be evaluated within a broader planning framework.
WHY TIMING MISTAKES HAPPEN
Most timing mistakes are not caused by carelessness. They happen because rollover rules are often encountered during moments of big transition when attention is already divided and decisions feel administrative rather than strategic.
​
In addition, employer plans rarely explain how rollover timing interacts with taxes, future income planning, or long-term flexibility. As a result, many investors make decisions that are reasaonable in isolation, only to discover later that certain opportunities quietly closed along the way.
​
A thoughtful review before assets are moved is often less about avoiding penalties and more about preserving optionality.
THE VALUE OF COORDINATED GUIDANCE
For investors with meaningful assets, a rollover is rarely just an investment decision. It intersects with tax planning, cash-flow strategy, estate considerations, and long-term risk management.
Our role is not to push assets from one account to another, but to help determine:
whether a rollover supports your broader strategy;
​
when timing matters and when it doesn't;
​
how the decision affects future flexibility, not just today's convenience; and
​
the investment and risk management strategies that will serve you best.
​
Who Our Guidance Is Designed For
This approach is well-suited for investors who have accumulated significant retirement assets and want decisions to be made deliberately, with an eye toward long-term coordination, and the assurance of an ongoing fiduciary advisory relationship.
Our discussion is designed to help you decide whether working together makes sense, not to rush you toward a conclusion.
YOUR NEXT STEP
If you're facing a rollover or considering an in-service distribution, and wondering whether it deserves further consideration and evaluation, a conversation can help clarify whether this is simply administrative or strategically important for you.
What is the difference between a direct and indirect rollover?
A direct rollover moves assets directly between custodians and typically avoids tax withholding. An indirect rollover involves receiving the funds personally and redepositing them within a limited timeframe, which introduces additional risk and potential tax consequences.
Do I have to roll over my 401k when I retire or change jobs?
No. A rollover is optional. In some cases, leaving assets in an employer plan can make sense, depending on investment options, fees, and future planning considerations.
What is an in-service distribution?
An in-service distribution allows eligible participants to roll part of their 401k into an IRA while still employed. Availability and rules vary by plan.
Are there tax consequences when rolling over a 401k?
A properly executed rollover is generally tax-free, but mistakes in timing or account selection can trigger unexpected taxes.
Is an IRA always better than a 401k?
Not necessarily. Each offers advantages, and the right structure often depends on how the account fits into your overall financial strategy.
When should I talk to a financial planner about a rollover?
Ideally before assets are moved. Once a rollover is completed, some planning opportunities may no longer be available.